Thanksgiving is supposed to be a time for gratitude, family, togetherness, and reflecting on everything we have to be thankful for.
But what if you're just not feeling it this year?
Maybe you've experienced the loss of someone you love. Maybe you're struggling with financial stress, family tension, anxiety, or simply feeling overwhelmed by everything life has thrown your way.
Or maybe you can't quite explain why, but the holidays just don't feel the same anymore.
Sound familiar?
Everywhere we look this time of year, we're reminded to count our blessings, appreciate what we have, and focus on the positive.
And while gratitude can be a wonderful practice for our emotional well-being, sometimes the pressure to feel thankful becomes one more thing we think we're doing wrong.
Here's something I want you to remember:
You can be grateful for the good things in your life and still have a difficult day.
Those two experiences are not mutually exclusive.
When Gratitude Starts Feeling Like Another Expectation
Have you ever shared that you were struggling, only to hear someone respond with:
"At least you have your health."
"You should be thankful for what you have."
"Other people have it so much worse."
Most of the time, these comments come from people who genuinely want us to feel better.
But sometimes, instead of helping, they leave us feeling guilty for having perfectly normal emotions.
We start questioning ourselves.
Why am I so unhappy when I have so much to be thankful for?
Why can't I just enjoy the holidays like everyone else?
Am I being selfish for wanting things to be different?
And before we know it, we're not only dealing with whatever was upsetting us in the first place. We're also criticizing ourselves for feeling upset.
That's a lot of emotional pressure to put on yourself, isn't it?
The truth is that gratitude isn't supposed to be another standard we have to live up to.
It's not about pretending everything is wonderful or convincing ourselves that our problems don't matter.
It's about recognizing moments of appreciation while still making room for the full range of human emotions.
Can You Feel Two Things at Once?
Absolutely!
Think about some of the situations you might experience around Thanksgiving.
You can love your family and still feel overwhelmed by spending an entire day together.
You can appreciate having a home and still feel stressed about paying the bills.
You can be thankful for the people around your table and still deeply miss someone who is no longer there.
You can enjoy certain holiday traditions and still feel anxious about everything you need to get done.
One feeling doesn't cancel out the other.
Yet so many of us fall into the habit of thinking that if we're grateful, we shouldn't feel sad, frustrated, anxious, or disappointed.
But who made that rule?
Our emotions aren't always neat and organized. Sometimes we experience joy and sadness in the very same moment.
And that's part of being human.
Instead of asking yourself why you aren't feeling more thankful, consider asking:
"Can I allow myself to appreciate what's good without dismissing what's difficult?"
That small change in perspective can make a meaningful difference.
What Does Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) Teach Us About Gratitude?
In Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), we explore the connection between our thoughts, emotions, and behaviors.
Sometimes, it's not just a difficult situation that's causing us distress. It's also the way we're interpreting that situation.
Let's look at an example.
Imagine it's Thanksgiving morning.
You're feeling exhausted, stressed about preparing dinner, and sad because someone important won't be joining you this year.
Then you catch yourself thinking:
1. Automatic Thought
"I should be happy today. It's Thanksgiving, and I have so much to be grateful for. What's wrong with me?"
Notice the word should.
When we tell ourselves how we should feel, we can create unrealistic emotional expectations.
2. Emotional Response
That thought might leave you feeling guilty, frustrated, ashamed, or even more upset than you were before.
Now, instead of simply acknowledging that you're having a difficult morning, you're judging yourself for it.
3. Challenge the Thought
Here's where CBT encourages us to slow down and examine what we're telling ourselves.
Ask yourself:
Does being grateful mean I have to feel happy all the time?
Am I expecting myself to experience the holidays a certain way?
Would I judge a friend for feeling sad or overwhelmed on Thanksgiving?
Is there a more compassionate way to look at this situation?
4. A Healthier Perspective
Instead of telling yourself that you should be happy, try:
"I have things in my life that I'm thankful for, and I'm also having a difficult day. Both can be true."
Or perhaps:
"It's okay to miss someone, feel overwhelmed, or need a little space. That doesn't mean I'm ungrateful."
See the difference?
The circumstances haven't necessarily changed, but the way you're responding to yourself has.
You're no longer fighting your emotions or adding another layer of guilt.
You're practicing a more balanced and compassionate way of thinking.
And that's an important part of emotional well-being.
Gratitude vs. Toxic Positivity: What's the Difference?
You may have heard the term toxic positivity.
It's the idea that we should maintain a positive attitude regardless of how difficult or painful a situation might be.
It can sound like:
"Just look on the bright side."
"Everything happens for a reason."
"Don't be sad. You have so much to be thankful for."
While these statements may be intended to offer comfort, they can sometimes minimize someone's emotional experience.
Healthy gratitude works differently.
It doesn't ask us to ignore our problems.
It doesn't require us to pretend we're happy.
And it certainly doesn't mean we should feel guilty for experiencing difficult emotions.
Instead, healthy gratitude allows us to acknowledge what's challenging while also noticing moments of comfort, connection, or appreciation.
For example:
Forced positivity: "I shouldn't feel sad today. I need to focus on being thankful."
Healthy gratitude: "I'm feeling sad today, and I also appreciate having someone who cares enough to check on me."
The second response makes room for both experiences.
And sometimes, that emotional flexibility is exactly what we need.
What If Thanksgiving Is Especially Difficult This Year?
For some people, Thanksgiving is a wonderful opportunity to reconnect with loved ones.
For others, it can bring up painful memories, complicated relationships, or reminders of what's missing.
Perhaps this is your first Thanksgiving without someone you love.
Maybe you're spending the holiday alone.
Maybe family gatherings bring more anxiety than excitement.
Or perhaps you're navigating a major life change, such as a divorce, job loss, health challenge, or financial hardship.
If that's where you find yourself this year, I want to remind you of something:
You don't have to force yourself to experience Thanksgiving the way everyone else seems to be experiencing it.
It's okay to change a tradition.
It's okay to decline an invitation.
It's okay to step away from a difficult conversation.
It's okay to take a moment for yourself.
And it's okay if this year's Thanksgiving looks different from what you imagined.
Sometimes, the kindest thing we can do for ourselves is to let go of the expectation that everything has to feel a certain way.
CBT & Mindfulness Minute: Practicing Gratitude Without the Pressure
This Thanksgiving, I'd like you to try a simple exercise.
Rather than making a long list of everything you think you should be thankful for, start with something much smaller.
Step 1: Check In With Yourself
Take a quiet moment and ask:
"How am I actually feeling right now?"
Maybe you're happy, tired, anxious, sad, peaceful, or a combination of several emotions.
Whatever comes up, try to acknowledge it without judging yourself.
You don't need to change how you feel.
Just notice it.
Step 2: Notice One Small Thing
Instead of asking, "What should I be grateful for?" ask:
"What's one small thing I can appreciate in this moment?"
Maybe it's:
A warm cup of coffee before the day gets busy.
The smell of your favorite Thanksgiving dish.
A phone call from someone who cares about you.
A quiet moment away from the noise.
A beautiful fall afternoon.
A memory that brings you comfort.
Simply making it through a difficult week.
It doesn't have to be something extraordinary.
And if nothing comes to mind right away, that's okay, too.
Step 3: Practice a More Compassionate Thought
If you notice yourself thinking:
"I should be happier."
Try replacing it with:
"I can appreciate this moment without expecting myself to feel differently."
Or:
"I'm allowed to have a difficult day and still find moments of gratitude."
The goal isn't to convince yourself that everything is perfect.
It's to practice noticing what's meaningful without putting pressure on yourself to feel a certain way.
A Gentle Reminder This Thanksgiving
As we approach Thanksgiving, I hope you'll remember that gratitude is not a competition.
You don't have to prove how thankful you are.
You don't have to compare your circumstances to someone else's.
And you don't have to turn every difficult experience into a positive lesson.
Sometimes life is wonderful.
Sometimes life is difficult.
And sometimes, it's both at the same time.
If this Thanksgiving brings joy, I hope you enjoy every moment of it.
If it brings sadness, stress, or complicated emotions, I hope you'll give yourself permission to experience those feelings without judgment.
And if you're somewhere in between?
That's okay, too.
You can be grateful and still have a hard day. You can appreciate your life and still wish certain things were different. And you can practice gratitude without pretending everything is perfect.
This Thanksgiving, instead of focusing on everything you think you should feel, try extending yourself a little more patience, understanding, and compassion.
After all, you deserve the same kindness you so freely offer to others.
Wishing you a peaceful and meaningful Thanksgiving.
Take good care,
Dawn O'Meally, LCSW-C
The Counseling Center for Change